Arsene Lupin, Gentleman Thief by
Maurice Leblanc My rating:
4 of 5 stars Amazon.in Page
Out:
This is a beautifully illustrated edition of the first collection of stories featuring the fictional burglar-extraordinaire, Arsène Lupin. While some of the nine stories reference others, they each read standalone.
Arsène Lupin is the Sherlock Holmes of crime. Like Holmes, he's extremely intelligent, gifted in observation, with deep insight into human nature, and with a range of practical skills from hand-to-hand combat to disguise, but Lupin puts these talents to use for the purpose of theft. While one might think of Prof. Moriarty as "the Sherlock Holmes of crime," Lupin operates by a code, eschewing senseless violence, carefully targeting his victims, and returning items he feels inappropriately taken. (Mirroring how Holmes occasionally lets a [technically] guilty party go free due to extenuating circumstances.) Besides cameo references to Holmes in multiple stories, the final story pits England's greatest detective against France's greatest burglar (though in a way that mostly allows each to retain an unblemished record and mutual admiration.)
I found these stories to be enjoyable to read, and generally clever, but – having been forced to make the comparison due to the repeated references to Holmes - I couldn't help but see their inferiorty to the stories of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Lupin is more one-dimensional and fantastical than Holmes. In Holmes, one recognizes that one is unlikely to get extreme intelligence without some sort of countervailing cognitive challenges – e.g. Holmes is an addict who needs to fill his days with work lest he fill them with heroin, and for all his great observational skills, Holmes frequently doesn't recognize when he's offending others with his brusque nature and sense of superiority. Lupin can come off as an arrogant jerk (he recognizes that he's being narcissistic, but doesn't care) but it seems we're supposed to conclude that he's just that good. Lupin is a fantastical mix of super intelligence, preternatural charm, and zero weaknesses – i.e. a perfect being made for pure escapism.
The stories are enjoyable and the art is beautifully rendered, and if you can avoid comparing it to Sherlock Holes and take it as mere escapism, you'll likely find this book pleasing.
View all my reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment